April 27, 2007
 
Ethanol Industry Refutes Stanford E85 Study | CFDC
 
Ethanol Industry Proponents Continue to Refute Stanford E85 Study

 

The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is the latest to join in the debate against the recently published Stanford report characterizing E85 as being more polluting than gasoline. The NRDC also strongly disagrees with Dr. Jacobson's conclusions. CFDC is excited about the onslaught of support we are receiving from such credible organizations such as NRDC and the Renewable Energy Action Project (REAP). We have also included the comments from the GEC and ACE on our website.  Immediately following the NRDC statement is a copy of an article that appeared in the Biofuels Journal regarding the possibility of ExxonMobil supporting Stanford, and possibly the study by Jacobson.

 

 

---

 

 

NRDC Statement on New Study of Ethanol (E85) Impact on Air Quality,

April 26, 2007

 

NRDC believes there should be no rush to judgment on the impacts of ethanol used as high blends (E85, 85% ethanol, and 15% gasoline) on air quality based on a new study by Mark Z. Jacobson of Stanford University.

 

We urge Dr. Jacobson to join with NRDC, air pollution regulators, and scientists to clear the air regarding his statement that concludes that E85, “a high blend of ethanol poses an equal or greater risk to public health than gasoline.” This conclusion is at odds with previous studies and emission data from modern vehicles running on E85, and even appears to be at odds with the conclusion from his own study.

 

NRDC recommends the following to clarify the results of this paper and the air quality impacts of ethanol used as high blends:

 

·     First, NRDC recommends that a team of leading vehicle emission experts review the existing data on emissions from E85. Based on this review, if the panel believes the emission scenarios in Dr. Jacobson’s study are incorrect and/or additional sensitivity runs are necessary, air pollution regulators should re-run the air pollution model to develop a broader scientific consensus of the impacts on air quality.

 

·     Second, based on the results from the above work, we urge the CARB, US EPA, automakers and the ethanol industry to commit to additional testing of E85 vehicles if warranted. If such testing results indicate a need, we call upon CARB and US EPA to immediately set tighter emission standards on E85 vehicles to protect public health.

 

We look forward to working with Dr. Jacobson and vehicle emission experts to clarify and improve the quality of information being provided to policymakers and the public on this important issue of the pollution impacts of E85.

 

Roland Hwang, Vehicles Policy Director
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL,
www.nrdc.org

111 Sutter Street, 20th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
tel: 415-875-6100
fax: 415-875-6161

 

Biofuels Journal, April 27, 2007

 

Group Says Stanford University Ethanol Study Tainted by ExxonMobil Ties (Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights)

 

Santa Monica, CA -- A widely reported study sounding an alarm against using ethanol to replace gasoline is the most recent example of Stanford University's energy research credibility being undercut by the school's ties to ExxonMobil Corp., the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights (FTCR) said April 26.

 

Mark Z. Jacobson, an associate professor of civil and environmental engineering, found that "a blend of ethanol poses an equal or greater [environmental health] risk than gasoline, which already causes significant health damage." His paper published in the online edition of Environmental Science and Technology said the research, based on computer models, was partly funded by NASA. The model is controversial because it assumes full conversion to ethanol use rather than partial. ExxonMobil has given $100 million to fund Stanford's Global Climate and Energy Program (GCEP). Though the ethanol study was not funded by that program, Jacobson had a three-year grant from GCEP to study the impact of replacing fossil-fuel motor vehicles and electric power plants with hydrogen fuel cell vehicles and power plants.

 

He is featured throughout a brochure about the Global Climate and Energy Program.

"It's difficult to accept a controversial study throwing cold water on the accepted idea that blended ethanol is a good solution to our energy problems when the university well that produced the study has been poisoned by Big Oil's money," said John M. Simpson, an FTCR advocate.

 

The science behind Jacobson's ethanol study could well be valid, FTCR said. However, the public cannot accept the results at face value when ExxonMobil has funded a major energy research program at the university and research results are in line with the giant oil firm's corporate goals, FTCR said. ExxonMobil Chairman Rex Tillerson is dismissive of ethanol's prospects, recently telling Fortune Magazine, "I don't have a lot of technology to add to moonshine." Jacobson said his ethanol work was not influenced by the corporate funding to the GCEP. "I completely oppose ExxonMobil and what it stands for," he said. He added that the results for the hydrogen research funded by GCEP, "resulted in me showing how unhealthful gasoline was relative to hydrogen, so it is certainly not a benefit to the oil companies."

 

Under the GCEP agreement ExxonMobil could control any patented results of hydrogen research, FTCR noted. "That's the problem when a university's administration takes Big Oil's cash and becomes part of Big Oil U.," said Simpson. "Even the very best work by its faculty members is greeted with justifiable skepticism from the public. "It's in the best interests of faculty and students alike to resist this corporatization of higher education."

The GCEP is managed and controlled by its corporate sponsors, not the university, FTCR noted. ExxonMobil has given $100 million to the GCEP. Other sponsors are Schlumberger, Toyota and General Electric. Exxon, along with the other partners, receives five-year exclusive rights to any discoveries resulting from the research.  The program is overseen by a management committee comprised of the corporate sponsors.

The university has no vote on the committee, meaning that the research agenda can be set by the sponsoring firms. The committee can decide what patents will be sought. BP has proposed a similar $500 million deal with UC Berkeley that would create the Energy Biosciences Institute. That deal would bring 50 BP scientists to campus to do proprietary research and is under fire by many faculty members and students. The Berkeley administration hopes to sign the deal this summer.

 

At Stanford, ExxonMobil is touting its relationship with the university in a major advertising campaign. Objecting to ExxonMobil's greenwashing campaign, movie producer Steve Bing, who attended Stanford and had donated $22.5 million to the school, protested recently by canceling a $2.5 million pledge and any future donations.

 

 





See what's free at AOL.com.